The Knesset has taken a first step toward establishing a formal inquiry into the failures surrounding the October 7, 2023 Hamas attack, advancing a controversial bill that has sharply divided Israel’s political leadership. Lawmakers approved the measure in a first reading by a vote of 59 to 0, with opposition members boycotting the ballot.

The legislation, promoted by a Likud lawmaker, would create a six member investigative committee. Under the proposal, appointing the committee and its chairman would require a broad Knesset supermajority of 80 out of 120 members. If no agreement is reached within a set period, the coalition and opposition would each select members, joined by supervisory figures representing bereaved families. The bill still requires two additional readings and is expected to return to committee ahead of possible final votes.

Supporters argue that the framework offers a structured, balanced way to examine one of the gravest days in the nation’s history, with defined roles for families of the victims, and that a state appointed body can proceed even amid political gridlock.

Opponents see the measure very differently. Opposition leaders argue that allowing the government that was in power during the attack to shape the body investigating its own conduct undermines the inquiry’s independence. They have vowed not to cooperate, and pledged that a future government would instead establish a state commission of inquiry, the more independent mechanism traditionally used in Israel for major national failures. Yair Lapid and Gadi Eisenkot were among those who condemned the vote.

The dispute reflects a deeper struggle over accountability for October 7. Many bereaved families and survivors have demanded an independent investigation into what went wrong before and during the attack, and their calls have grown louder as Israel recently marked more than 1,000 days since that day. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who did not take part in the vote, has resisted calls to accept personal responsibility.

With elections approaching, the debate over how to investigate October 7 is likely to remain one of the most charged issues in Israeli public life.

+ posts